The Best Places To Buy Seafood Online
When you’re shopping for seafood online, you want to make sure you’re getting a top-notch product. Of course, some companies are more reputable than others in terms of quality and consistency. That’s why we’ve put together this list of the best online seafood purveyors.
Charleston Seafood
The waters off South Carolina offer some of the most delectable seafood you’ll find anywhere. Because this Charleston-based company processes and ships every order from the same location, their attention to detail is excellent.
Buyers can choose between salmon, halibut, swordfish, tuna, trout, catfish, sea bass, and many more. Charleston Seafood also offers wild-caught fresh shrimp and king crab legs, along with bivalves such as oysters, mussels, and clams. You can even order delicacies such as escargot and caviar from their specialty department. If you’re looking for the perfect gift for that seafood lover in your life, gift certificates are available online as well.
Fulton Fish Market
Founded in New York City in 1822, Fulton Fish Market has the distinction of being one of the longest-running seafood operations in the US. In 2005, the company set up a 400,000-square foot market in the Bronx, where they receive more than 2 million tons of fresh seafood every day.
If it’s wild-caught fish you’re after, Fulton has you covered with options such as monkfish, halibut, sea scallops, and Alaskan sockeye salmon, to name just a few. You can also order live Blue Point oysters by the dozen for special occasions. Their “bundle” packages are a great bargain for shoppers who prefer to buy in bulk.
Alaskan King Crab Company
As you might have guessed, king crab legs are this outfit’s claim to fame. However, although the company prides itself on its prime location along Alaska’s Bering Sea, that’s not all they offer. Black cod, Alaskan halibut and sockeye salmon, and Florida stone crab are just some of the selections you’ll find on their list.
Every offering from Alaskan King Crab is wild-caught and responsibly sourced, and the company takes care to buy from legacy fishermen and -women whenever possible. If you purchase over 4 pounds of king crab from Monday through Thursday, you’ll receive free shipping on your order.
Sizzlefish
This business was born after its founder came up with the idea during a training run. Because physical fitness goes hand-in-hand with a healthy diet, they decided to offer athletes a way to have heart-healthy fish and shellfish delivered straight to their door.
The company is based out of North Carolina, which is a haven for seafood lovers. In addition to fresh sablefish, rockfish, sea bass, and grouper, they offer dietary advice and recipe ideas to supplement their product. Sizzlefish offers many wild-caught options, including Gulf shrimp, Atlantic cod, Alaska halibut, and sea scallops.
When visiting their website, check the top of the screen—they may be running a special that day. On one occasion, Sizzlefish was offering a free pound of shrimp with every order.
Vital Choice
Unlike some of the companies listed here, Vital Choice offers only wild-caught, sustainable seafood from its online market. The company was founded in the Pacific Northwest in 2001, and while wild Alaskan salmon is their specialty, their appeal is much broader than that.
There’s an extensive list of fresh fish available, but buyers can also choose from canned and pouched products for portability and convenience. Other proteins, such as grass-fed beef and bison, are also available, along with dietary supplements and seasonings. As of this writing, Vital Choice was offering free shipping on all orders over $99.
Lobster Anywhere
New Englanders tend to believe that their seafood is the best, and many people who have visited the region agree. Lobster Anywhere, located in Massachusetts, wants to bring that quality right to your door.
Order live lobsters, cooked lobster meat, or the cooked tails only. You can also make it easier on yourself by opting for a prepared chowder or a bisque. Other seafood selections are on offer—Prince Edward Island mussels and North Atlantic sea scallops, for example—but the lobster is the star here.
Luke’s Lobster
This company got its start in New York City, but today it has multiple locations all around the globe. Lobster and crab are the top selections at Luke’s, but you can also purchase Gulf of Maine monkfish fillets and day boat scallops from their extensive online market. Our favorite selection is the Mother’s Day gift package, which includes hand-crafted chocolates in addition to freshly made lobster rolls.
Goldbelly
It can be a bit of a challenge to navigate Goldbelly, which is a full-on food service website. However, if you’re looking for a great deal on Alaskan crab legs, check out the Pike Place Fish Market. They’ll send along a batch of pre-cooked, previously frozen king crab legs for your next gathering, directly from the Seattle seafood market.
The California-based San Pedro Fish Market is another good choice, offering delightful seafood feasts for 2 to 6 people. Be aware that these selections will need to be cooked within 24 hours once they arrive at your doorstep.
Omaha Steaks
If you’ve only sampled Omaha’s filet mignon and premium sirloin steaks, you’re missing out. Although their beef selection is undoubtedly fine, you can also rely on this Nebraskan company for premium seafood. Their fish is always responsibly sourced, and wild-caught selections (such as grouper) are usually available. Be sure to browse the Omaha Steaks website for side dishes and dessert ideas—their baked stuffed potatoes and caramel apple tartlets are wonderful.
Click here for more Omaha Steaks selections:
Island Creek Oysters
These precious bivalves come straight from Duxbury Bay in Massachusetts, just begging for a squeeze of lemon and a dash of cocktail sauce. Island Creek Oysters utilizes a “tide to table” mentality, with daily harvesting and free shipping to ensure freshness. If you’re in the Duxbury area, you can also pick up your oysters at their charming brick-and-mortar store. As a bonus, you can find helpful shucking tips on their easily navigable website.
Taylor Shellfish Farms
This company has been harvesting shellfish out of the Pacific Northwest since the turn of the 20th century. While they have several physical locations, they also offer nationwide shipping.
In addition to oysters, Taylor Shellfish Farms sells canned tuna and smoked seafood, as well as mussels, Manila clams, and flash-frozen geoduck. If you prefer your oysters fried, pick up a bag of Willabay Oyster Breading for premium results.
Hama Hama Oysters
Hama Hama is another Washington-based oyster company, and one that’s been harvesting their product for five generations. Hama Hama oysters and Blue Pool oysters are available in sets of 3 dozen apiece, while Manila clams are sold in 5-pound bags. Their website is updated frequently with new recipes and other menu ideas, so be sure to check in often.
Keys Fisheries
As you can probably guess from the name, this company is located in the Florida Keys, so if conch is high on your hit list, this could be the place for you. Keys Fisheries is a restaurant in addition to an online retailer, so their product moves quickly. While their offerings aren’t as extensive as some of the competition, their list does include a number of tasty accompaniments, such as tartar sauce, panko breadcrumbs, and Key Lime pie.
Maine Lobster Now
Every summer, tourists flock to Maine in droves for the opportunity to sample some of the state’s famous lobster. The sweet crustacean is a state symbol, which is why Maine Lobster Now decided to begin shipping it out of its Portland facility. Now you can enjoy a lobster feast without making your way up the Atlantic coastline.
Maine Lobster Now allows you to choose between live and cooked lobster, so you can either prepare it yourself or let someone else do the hard work. Dishes like lobster mac and cheese and New England clam chowder are available as well. If there’s someone in your party who’s not crazy about shellfish, they can select wild-caught Alaskan sablefish, Icelandic haddock, or North Atlantic swordfish instead.
Costco
Costco might not be the first name you think of when you’re deciding where to buy seafood online. However, they do feature Alaskan king crab legs at a reasonable price. You might also find wild-caught Alaskan cod or sockeye salmon sold in bulk, which is great news if you like to keep your freezer full.
Whole Foods
Did you know there’s a Whole Foods Market with delivery available for Amazon Prime members? It might not be the most obvious choice for home seafood delivery, but this is just one of the many ways in which your Prime membership can be put to good use. Obvious selections such as wild-caught shrimp and snapper are available, along with more exotic offerings like octopus and sturgeon caviar.
Instacart
When you sign up with Instacart, you can have groceries delivered from your local market right to your door. Major supermarket chains such as Publix should always have wild-caught flounder, shrimp, and other seafood on their list of available offerings. Smaller outfits like Fresh Market might be able to fill in the gaps if you can’t find what you’re looking for. You can also use the website to find small mom-and-pop stores in your area that deliver via Instacart, thereby customizing the experience–and getting the freshest seafood your money can buy.
Now that you know where to find the best seafood online, you can plan heart-healthy meals all year round. Instead of waiting until your local supermarket offers a deal on your favorite type of fish, you’ll be in full control of your menu.